Carly Rae Jepsen NAILS Taylor Swift's signature surprised face!

We'd like to congratulate Carly Rae Jepsen on officially being inducted into the "Taylor Swift Surprised Face" club! It's a coveted (and totally made up) organization that Niall Horan, Katy Perry, Lana Del Rey, and a gazillion more famous people also belong to! Oh, and if you're wondering how you can apply for a membership... Well, you can't. It's only for super talented/famous pop stars. (We realize that this means we can't even be a member of a club we made up, but whatever -- rules are rules.)

The "Tonight I'm Getting Over You" singer was snapped looking all kinds of shocked while visiting a radio station in Toronto to promote a new line of beauty products. But now we're wondering what made Carly look so shocked in the first place! Did she spot an old BFF? Were there a BILLION adoring fans waiting to greet her outside the radio station? Did she see some adorbz puppies in the window?? Because that is the EXACT face we make when WE spy puppies from across the street! We're just going to guess that ALL three of these things happened. After all, it takes a LOT to conjure up a true "Taylor Swift Surprise" face.

Photo credit: Pacific Coast News/ PictureGroup